The temp love trap - how to avoid it

When you're in love, it's too late
Nyamka Ganbold

The temp love trap - how to avoid it

When you're in love, it's too late
Nyamka Ganbold

There is this “temp music” editors and directors work with until the final score is finished. This temporary music helps to see how the picture works and flows with music and gives the scene direction on how it is supposed to feel. This is the first time directors see the scene working and flowing. And here comes the problem. The temp love trap. The director falls in love with the temp music and often wants to have the score composed as closely as possible to the temp music.

The British composer Christian Henson says on his youtube channel that the temp itself is not the problem, but it’s the temp love. “I think, what we fear the most are four words connected with this kind of love. But it’s not ‘will you marry me’ or ‘I want a child’ it’s ‘copy the fucking temp’.

Yes, this sounds very serious. And it is. 

Once the temp love trap happens it's pretty painful.

Even the world famous composer Danny Elfman agrees on it. He once said that temp music is the bane of his existence. “I won’t listen to it but once, and if they’re addicted to it, it’s just going to make my job harder.”

It certainly makes the job harder. But there are also ways you can avoid or prevent this trap. You can simply use a temp track that you can afford in case everyone is wedded to that music and there is no way out of it. Or you can try to use the temp music for as short a time period as possible. These are ordinary ways you can stay out of the trap. But in this article we want to present you our TOP TWO ways of avoiding or preventing temp love trap.

Before we talk about how to avoid the temp love trap, we should be aware of the types of temp love.

In his very amusing youtube video "What is TEMP Music" (which we definitely recommend to watch) Christian Henson demonstrates with valuable score examples the different types of temp loves composers are faced with. We want to reveal few of them we could relate the most with.

  1. Pricey temp: You’ve been given 10 days to write a score and a budget to record it with three string players in Turkmenistan. And they question why there is a solid difference between what you’re doing and the temp, which they’ve been using from The DaVinci Code.
  2. Resonant temp: They put a piece of music in the edit which is already familiar to everyone. This often would create an emotion, a resonance based on experience the viewer has already had of this piece of music.
  3. Unicorn temp: They take a piece of music that is just one of a kind. It has a weird selection of instruments or a very unique kind of definitive harmonic language or instrumentation/orchestration. And the minute you start adopting any of those elements you’re accused of plagiarism.
If it plays as a silent movie, if you can read it and it's clear and smooth and creamy, you know it will play with sound and the music.

We know that 90% of films out there are being done using temp music in post-production. And as Danny Elfman said in an interview for Los Angeles Times: “There has been temp music for over 30 years. The fact of the matter is you can’t preview a movie without a temp track.

This leads us right into our FIRST WAY on how to avoid or prevent temp love trap: 

‍Involve the composer as early as possible.

role
age
favorite movie

There is this “temp music” editors and directors work with until the final score is finished. This temporary music helps to see how the picture works and flows with music and gives the scene direction on how it is supposed to feel. This is the first time directors see the scene working and flowing. And here comes the problem. The temp love trap. The director falls in love with the temp music and often wants to have the score composed as closely as possible to the temp music.

The British composer Christian Henson says on his youtube channel that the temp itself is not the problem, but it’s the temp love. “I think, what we fear the most are four words connected with this kind of love. But it’s not ‘will you marry me’ or ‘I want a child’ it’s ‘copy the fucking temp’.

Yes, this sounds very serious. And it is. 

Once the temp love trap happens it's pretty painful.

Even the world famous composer Danny Elfman agrees on it. He once said that temp music is the bane of his existence. “I won’t listen to it but once, and if they’re addicted to it, it’s just going to make my job harder.”

It certainly makes the job harder. But there are also ways you can avoid or prevent this trap. You can simply use a temp track that you can afford in case everyone is wedded to that music and there is no way out of it. Or you can try to use the temp music for as short a time period as possible. These are ordinary ways you can stay out of the trap. But in this article we want to present you our TOP TWO ways of avoiding or preventing temp love trap.

The temp love trap - how to avoid it

Before we talk about how to avoid the temp love trap, we should be aware of the types of temp love.

In his very amusing youtube video "What is TEMP Music" (which we definitely recommend to watch) Christian Henson demonstrates with valuable score examples the different types of temp loves composers are faced with. We want to reveal few of them we could relate the most with.

  1. Pricey temp: You’ve been given 10 days to write a score and a budget to record it with three string players in Turkmenistan. And they question why there is a solid difference between what you’re doing and the temp, which they’ve been using from The DaVinci Code.
  2. Resonant temp: They put a piece of music in the edit which is already familiar to everyone. This often would create an emotion, a resonance based on experience the viewer has already had of this piece of music.
  3. Unicorn temp: They take a piece of music that is just one of a kind. It has a weird selection of instruments or a very unique kind of definitive harmonic language or instrumentation/orchestration. And the minute you start adopting any of those elements you’re accused of plagiarism.
If it plays as a silent movie, if you can read it and it's clear and smooth and creamy, you know it will play with sound and the music.

We know that 90% of films out there are being done using temp music in post-production. And as Danny Elfman said in an interview for Los Angeles Times: “There has been temp music for over 30 years. The fact of the matter is you can’t preview a movie without a temp track.

This leads us right into our FIRST WAY on how to avoid or prevent temp love trap: 

‍Involve the composer as early as possible.